Friday Fiction Facts: Myths & Truths of Nature Lore
Welcome to Friday Fiction Facts: sciency things that fiction writers need to know.
Want to bring some nature lore into your novel? Before you do that, it would be a good idea to know whether the wisdom you’re about to include is true or just a myth. So, this week, a handful of oft-repeated bits of nature lore – some true, some not. And, because these are barely the tip of the iceberg, I’ve included some links at the end to help you navigate between myth and scientific reality when it comes to nature lore.
Woolly Bear Foreseeing Winter
Banded Woolly Bears (or Woolly Worms) are the fuzzy orange and black caterpillars of the Isabella tiger moth, Pyrrharctia Isabella. In the fall these furry creatures go on the march, looking for sheltered places to overwinter. Lore has it that the amount of orange on the caterpillar can be used to predict the upcoming winter – the less orange, the harsher the winter will be.
Unsurprisingly, the color ratio of the woolly bear has no relation to the future winter. Instead, the amount of black varies with the age of the caterpillar and how wet it was where the caterpillar developed.
The longer the caterpillar has been feeding and the bigger it has grown, the narrower are the red-orange bands girdling its middle. Thus, the width of the banding is an indicator of the current or past season’s growth rather than an indicator of the length of the upcoming winter. (Bill Oehlke)
Here is the thing about animals (or anything else in nature) predicting the weather – they can’t. There is no way for an animal or a plant to “foresee” what the future season is going to bring. Any response – thicker coat, more insulated nests, more hoarding of food—are all based on current or past conditions.
That’s not to say they can’t sense an impending storm or other near-future weather event. Many animals and plants are sensitive to changes in barometric pressure, temperature, and/or humidity. Some animals can also smell distant water or hear far off thunder better than we can. While this makes them seem prescient, in reality, they are sensing current conditions.
I know.. I know.. I take all the fun out of everything! Well here’s something you might like:
Counting Cricket Chirps to determine temperature
Supposedly you can tell the temperature outdoors by counting how often a cricket chirps in a given period of time. Male crickets use their legs to generate chirps (females do not chirp) so presumably, the colder the crickets are, the slower they move.
This turns out to be true, at least for some species of cricket. However, the question is: What is the conversion equation from cricket chirp to temperature? There are several formulas kicking around, including this one from The Old Farmer’s Almanac:
Number of chirps in 14 seconds + 40 = Temperature in Fahrenheit.
A number of people have tested this formula and, for the most part, it holds up pretty well. According to Snopes, Dr. Peggy LeMone, of Colorado, tested the relationship between crickets and temperature in the summer of 2007. Her findings showed that while …
Chirps in 15 seconds + 37 = T
..was a good approximation, her adjusted formula of:
Chirps in 13 seconds + 40 = T
…was even better. Her graphs are here: Graph 1 Graph 2 . So her results were almost spot-on with The Old Farmer’s Almanac version. This past summer Accuweather’s Adrienne Veilleux tested the Farmer’s Almanac formula using crickets she purchased at a pet store.
Finally, here’s an online cricket-temperature calculator based on:
Chirps in 15 seconds + 40 = T
It looks like you’ll have to test your own crickets to see which formula works best.
Porcupines (and hedgehogs) can shoot their quills at you
From a hollow tree the Hedgehog
With his sleepy eyes looked at him,
Shot his shining quills, like arrows,
Saying with a drowsy murmur,
Through the tangle of his whiskers,
Take my quills, O Hiawatha!
From the ground the quills he gathered,
All the shining little arrows…
Henry Wadsworth Longfellow, “The Song of Hiawatha”
I’m afraid Longfellow didn’t know much about Hedgehogs.
No it is not possible for a porcupine or a hedgehog to launch its quills at you any more than it’s possible for you to launch your hair at someone. Sure, the quills will fall out or can be pulled out, especially if they are imbedded in your dog, but they cannot be shot out in projectile fashion.
When a porcupine or hedgehog is threatened it raises its quills, much the way a cat raises its fur to look larger. If the creature bothering the porcupine doesn’t take a hint (in the way of most house dogs) the porcupine turns its back and lashes out with its tail. Perhaps people saw that behavior and though the animal was throwing its quills.
Mostly porcupines are easygoing rodents ….just a bit hard to play with without protection
Yes, I just wanted an excuse to post that video. Maybe you just want to skip all this nature lore and and add cute porcupine “puppy” to your novel.
TRUE, with a caveat: If you cut a worm in half, the FRONT half will live IF you cut it in the right place. First, some earthworm anatomy:
See the smooth section in the middle called the “clitellum”? You’ll notice all of the important bits are in front of that. The clitellum is important as well. It is art of the reproductive system of the earthworm. For the front half of the worm to survive, it must include the clitellum and at least 10 segments behind the clitellum.
But don’t do this, ok? It’s not really nice to cut up earthworms.
And, because I didn’t have time to find one more example, I’ll let you do that. Ask me a nature-related “is it real or myth?” question today (Friday only), and I’ll do my best to answer you in comments.
- National Wildlife Foundation: Six Common Nature Myths Debunked
- Twin Cities Naturalist: Top 10 Nature Myths Debunked
- Snopes: Wild Inaccuracies
- The Old Farmer’s Almanac: Weather Proverbs and Prognostics: Animals (for entertainment purposes)
Woolly Bear Photos by Denise Moynahan (and no, she doesn’t really believe they tell the future, though must admit, they called the snowstorm of Hurricane Sandy pretty darn accurately.)